Residents who remember the old Benjamin’s Saloon or later Camino Brewing Co. can watch the site at 702 and 718 S. First Street take on a new life. Jim Salata, president of San Jose-based Garden City Construction and Buccaneer Demolition, is converting the shuttered taproom and the neighboring historic building into a multi-phase food, drink, and events destination. He has already secured a Type 75 on-sale general brewpub license for the future Car Bar Brewery Restaurant space.
Salata envisions a brewpub-style operation centered on automotive memorabilia and artifacts tied to San Jose’s agricultural past. The space already holds a 10-barrel brewhouse. His company is handling kitchen refurbishments and upgrades to the front bar. “We're trying to get it to a point where we can bring in an operator and have a viable business,” Salata said. He hopes phase one, the brewery, will be close to done by the end of January. Camino Brewing closed in April 2024 after citing inflation and a slow recovery from the Covid-19 pandemic.
The next phase completes Benjamin’s Gardens, a shared outdoor space behind a newly completed front wall. Regular operations there will need the kitchen finished. A later phase restores the two-story building at 702 S. First Street into Benjamin’s Saloon, with potential for a full kitchen in the garage. The second floor will feature a vintage brothel-style design with red velvet wallpaper and brass fixtures. The building dates to 1884 and originally housed Benjamin’s Saloon until Prohibition. Other businesses followed before Faber’s Cyclery opened in 1923. Salata and his wife, Suzanne, bought the structure in 2013 after a fire damaged the then-129-year-old property. “That's when we rebuilt it with reclaimed materials,” Salata said. “It's quite a story of the materials that we found and how it all transpired. It's a story in itself.”
Memorabilia collected from local families, farms, and businesses will appear throughout the property, including a loaned collection of Schwinn Sting-Ray bicycles for display inside the future saloon. A roughly 12,000-square-foot parking lot near Second and Margaret streets holds space for about 30 vehicles. Salata said the project could split into three components: the Car Bar Brewery Restaurant, Benjamin’s Saloon, and a shared garden/event space, with separate operators or investors potentially involved in different portions.
The site sits in the SoFA district along South First Street. Once operators come on board, the phased approach could return a longtime neighborhood address to active use for dining, drinks, and gatherings.
Source: SVBJ














